Community profile

Autumn Bay of Pewaukee

539 E Wisconsin Avenue, Pewaukee, WI

Assisted LivingMemory Care

4.023 reviewsRead reviews

About the community

About Autumn Bay of Pewaukee

Autumn Bay of Pewaukee in Pewaukee, WI is one of senior living communities in the area. To find the right community for your needs and budget, connect with one of A Place For Mom’s local senior living advisors for free, expert advice.

Family and resident feedback

4.0 out of 5 from 23 reviews

Recent public reviews can help surface themes to ask about on a tour. Ratings belong to the original review source and are not independently verified by us.

★★★★★

Positive

Highly Recommend

My family and I would very highly recommend this assisted living facility to friends and family. They program is well developed and the staff is always kind and courteous to my grandmother. She really enjoys the meals and activities. The program director was extremely responsive and helpful when we were choosing a place for my grandma. We are so happy to have found this home away from home!

See category ratings
Cleanliness
5.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Value for Cost
5.0 / 5
Care Services
5.0 / 5
Activities
5.0 / 5
Staff
5.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
5.0 / 5
AnonymousAugust 5, 2025

★★★★★

Positive

Autumn Bay , a caring place for your loved one.

My family and loved one have had a good experience with Autumn Bay. The staff are kind, caring, and helpful. Everyone is friendly. This truly feels like a family atmosphere. There are meals and activities provided for the resident's socialization. Overall, this is a community we would recommend.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
4.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Value for Cost
3.0 / 5
Care Services
4.0 / 5
Activities
5.0 / 5
Staff
4.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
4.0 / 5
AnonymousJune 20, 2023

★★★★★

Positive

Home away from Home

Autumn Bay has some of the most trained and caring staff. It has a home away from home feel. The residents have privacy and can enjoy a quiet environment. I have always enjoyed being a part of this community as an outside medical provider. The management is organized and attentive to the families they serve. Definitely worth looking into.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
5.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Value for Cost
5.0 / 5
Care Services
5.0 / 5
Activities
4.0 / 5
Staff
5.0 / 5
Meals & Dining
4.0 / 5
Amy UnderbergDecember 24, 2022

★★★★★

Critical

Wonderful Caregiver- - POOR MANAGEMENT!!

My grandmother was a resident at Autumn Bay for just under a year. The caregivers were so sweet and so caring. You could tell they really cared about each and every resident there. They took the time to do her hair and paint her nails and do arts & crafts with her. Why I've given them a low rating is because of their terrible management. 2020 has been a crazy year with COVID-19. I understand the reasoning behind their strict visitation rules- at first. But when my grandmother was placed on hospice, arguing with t

See category ratings
Cleanliness
3.0 / 5
Friendliness
3.0 / 5
Value for Cost
2.0 / 5
Care Services
4.0 / 5
Activities
4.0 / 5
AnonymousOctober 17, 2020

★★★★★

Positive

A Facility that Cares

The staff are wonderful but my husband is having a hard time with adjusting to his medications. The staff are providing almost one on one care for him though. The facility is really nice, the location is great, and he has an excellent room. It is a one floor, small building on a quiet street in a lovely neighborhood with a wrap around back deck overlooking a river. It's really beautiful. The staff are so accommodating to the residents and they have residents at all levels of memory loss. The staff work really hard

See category ratings
Cleanliness
5.0 / 5
Friendliness
5.0 / 5
Value for Cost
5.0 / 5
Care Services
5.0 / 5
Activities
5.0 / 5
Irene SorensenApril 15, 2020

★★★★

Critical

I went to go visit my Grams today, I am beyond words how poorly she was treated and the way the staff talked about her while using profanity. How sad to the individuals that live there, I prayed the Lord watches over them all and the staff can find it in their hearts to be kind to all our loved ones that reside there.

See category ratings
Cleanliness
0.5 / 5
Friendliness
0.5 / 5
Value for Cost
0.5 / 5
Care Services
0.5 / 5
Activities
0.5 / 5
AnonymousAugust 3, 2018

Verified overview

What we know from public sources

Care options
Assisted Living, Memory Care
Operator
Not yet resolved
Public price status
Not publicly found
Last source check
August 11, 2026

Source-published features

Amenities and services

Grouped so you can scan what affects day-to-day life before opening an operator page.

Meals & dining

  • Meals Provided

Health & wellness

  • Memory Care
  • Diabetic Care
  • Staffing & Ancillary Services
  • Non-Ambulatory Care
  • Incontinence Care

Activities & engagement

  • Activities On-site
  • Devotional Activities Offsite

Outdoor spaces

  • Indoor Common Areas

Apartment & room features

  • Wheelchair Accessible Showers

Official oversight

Inspection and quality records

Inspection coverage has not yet been completed for this community. “Not covered” is not the same as “no violations found.”

Coverage last checked August 11, 2026.

Questions to confirm with the community

Additional care fees
Not publicly disclosed
Move-in fee
Not publicly disclosed
Exact unit availability
Confirmation required
Autumn Bay of Pewaukee – Pewaukee, WI | Find With Care